Fixed by storing a list of cached inodes for a key, instead of just one.
Backwards compatability note: An old git-annex version will fail to parse
an inode cache file that has been written by a new version, and has
multiple items. It will succees if just one. So old git-annexes will have
even worse behavior when there are duplicated files, if that is possible.
I don't think it will be a problem. (Famous last words.)
Also, note that it doesn't expire old and unused inode caches for a key.
It would be possible to add this if needed; just look through the
associated files for a key and if there are more cached inodes, throw out
any not corresponding to associated files. Unless a file is being copied
repeatedly and the old copy deleted, this lack of expiry should not be a
problem.
* since this is a crippled filesystem anyway, git-annex doesn't use
symlinks on it
* so there's no reason to use the mixed case hash directories that we're
stuck using to avoid breaking everyone's symlinks to the content
* so we can do what is already done for all bare repos, and make non-bare
repos on crippled filesystems use the all-lower case hash directories
* which are, happily, all 3 letters long, so they cannot conflict with
mixed case hash directories
* so I was able to 100% fix this and even resuming `git annex add` in the
test case will recover and it will all just work.
This avoids commit churn by the assistant when eg,
replacing a file with a symlink.
But, just as importantly, it prevents the working tree being left with a
deleted file if git-annex, or perhaps the whole system, crashes at the
wrong time.
(It also probably avoids confusing displays in file managers.)
There are two types of equality here, and which one is right varies,
so this forces me to consider and choose between them.
Based on this, I learned that the commit in git anex sync was
always doing a strong comparison, even when in a repository where
the inodes had changed. Fixed that.
Refactored annex link code into nice clean new library.
Audited and dealt with calls to createSymbolicLink.
Remaining calls are all safe, because:
Annex/Link.hs: ( liftIO $ createSymbolicLink linktarget file
only when core.symlinks=true
Assistant/WebApp/Configurators/Local.hs: createSymbolicLink link link
test if symlinks can be made
Command/Fix.hs: liftIO $ createSymbolicLink link file
command only works in indirect mode
Command/FromKey.hs: liftIO $ createSymbolicLink link file
command only works in indirect mode
Command/Indirect.hs: liftIO $ createSymbolicLink l f
refuses to run if core.symlinks=false
Init.hs: createSymbolicLink f f2
test if symlinks can be made
Remote/Directory.hs: go [file] = catchBoolIO $ createSymbolicLink file f >> return True
fast key linking; catches failure to make symlink and falls back to copy
Remote/Git.hs: liftIO $ catchBoolIO $ createSymbolicLink loc file >> return True
ditto
Upgrade/V1.hs: liftIO $ createSymbolicLink link f
v1 repos could not be on a filesystem w/o symlinks
Audited and dealt with calls to readSymbolicLink.
Remaining calls are all safe, because:
Annex/Link.hs: ( liftIO $ catchMaybeIO $ readSymbolicLink file
only when core.symlinks=true
Assistant/Threads/Watcher.hs: ifM ((==) (Just link) <$> liftIO (catchMaybeIO $ readSymbolicLink file))
code that fixes real symlinks when inotify sees them
It's ok to not fix psdueo-symlinks.
Assistant/Threads/Watcher.hs: mlink <- liftIO (catchMaybeIO $ readSymbolicLink file)
ditto
Command/Fix.hs: stopUnless ((/=) (Just link) <$> liftIO (catchMaybeIO $ readSymbolicLink file)) $ do
command only works in indirect mode
Upgrade/V1.hs: getsymlink = takeFileName <$> readSymbolicLink file
v1 repos could not be on a filesystem w/o symlinks
Audited and dealt with calls to isSymbolicLink.
(Typically used with getSymbolicLinkStatus, but that is just used because
getFileStatus is not as robust; it also works on pseudolinks.)
Remaining calls are all safe, because:
Assistant/Threads/SanityChecker.hs: | isSymbolicLink s -> addsymlink file ms
only handles staging of symlinks that were somehow not staged
(might need to be updated to support pseudolinks, but this is
only a belt-and-suspenders check anyway, and I've never seen the code run)
Command/Add.hs: if isSymbolicLink s || not (isRegularFile s)
avoids adding symlinks to the annex, so not relevant
Command/Indirect.hs: | isSymbolicLink s -> void $ flip whenAnnexed f $
only allowed on systems that support symlinks
Command/Indirect.hs: whenM (liftIO $ not . isSymbolicLink <$> getSymbolicLinkStatus f) $ do
ditto
Seek.hs:notSymlink f = liftIO $ not . isSymbolicLink <$> getSymbolicLinkStatus f
used to find unlocked files, only relevant in indirect mode
Utility/FSEvents.hs: | Files.isSymbolicLink s = runhook addSymlinkHook $ Just s
Utility/FSEvents.hs: | Files.isSymbolicLink s ->
Utility/INotify.hs: | Files.isSymbolicLink s ->
Utility/INotify.hs: checkfiletype Files.isSymbolicLink addSymlinkHook f
Utility/Kqueue.hs: | Files.isSymbolicLink s = callhook addSymlinkHook (Just s) change
all above are lower-level, not relevant
Audited and dealt with calls to isSymLink.
Remaining calls are all safe, because:
Annex/Direct.hs: | isSymLink (getmode item) =
This is looking at git diff-tree objects, not files on disk
Command/Unused.hs: | isSymLink (LsTree.mode l) = do
This is looking at git ls-tree, not file on disk
Utility/FileMode.hs:isSymLink :: FileMode -> Bool
Utility/FileMode.hs:isSymLink = checkMode symbolicLinkMode
low-level
Done!!
In indirect mode, now checks the inode cache to detect changes to a file.
Note that a file can still be changed if a process has it open for write,
after landing in the annex.
In direct mode, some checking of the inode cache was done before, but
from a much later point, so fewer modifications could be detected. Now it's
as good as indirect mode.
On crippled filesystems, no lock down is done before starting to add a
file, so checking the inode cache is the only protection we have.
git annex init probes for crippled filesystems, and sets direct mode, as
well as `annex.crippledfilesystem`.
Avoid manipulating permissions of files on crippled filesystems.
That would likely cause an exception to be thrown.
Very basic support in Command.Add for cripped filesystems; avoids the lock
down entirely since doing it needs both permissions and hard links.
Will make this better soon.
Avoid a crash if a mapping contains files that no longer exist.
This could happen because eg, one was deleted and a commit has not yet been
done to update the mapping.
Fix path calculation.
When a file is changed in direct mode, the old content is probably lost
(at least from the local repo), and bookeeping needs to be updated to
reflect this.
Also, synthetic add events are generated at assistant startup, so
make it detect when the file has not really changed, and avoid re-adding
it.
This does add the overhead of querying the runing git cat-file for the
key that's recorded in git for the file, each time a file is added or
modified in direct mode.
